Reply to “Comment to ‘Dynamics of supercooled confined water measured by deep inelastic neutron scattering’ by Y. Finkelstein and R. Moreh”

Antonio Cupane, Giovanni Romanelli

Risultato della ricerca: Comment/debate

Abstract

We reply to the comment [Front. Phys. 14(5), 53605 (2019)] by Y. Finkelstein and R. Moreh on our articleFront. Phys. 13(1), 138205(2018).Weagreewithsomeoftheircriticismsaboutourcalculation of the temperature effect on the kinetic energy of hydrogen atoms of supercooled confined water; we also agree with their statement that, in view of the current sensitivity of the technique, possible effects oftheliquid–liquidwatertransitionarehardlydetectedwithdeepinelasticneutronscattering(DINS). However, we disagree with their use of the translational mass ratio of a single water molecule and, in general, with their underestimation of collective effects.
Lingua originaleEnglish
Numero di pagine2
RivistaFrontiers of Physics
Volume14
Stato di pubblicazionePublished - 2019

Fingerprint

inelastic scattering
neutron scattering
mass ratios
water
temperature effects
hydrogen atoms
kinetic energy
sensitivity
molecules

All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes

  • Physics and Astronomy (miscellaneous)

Cita questo

@article{7372aaa54b98414f834a1466e8dee87a,
title = "Reply to “Comment to ‘Dynamics of supercooled confined water measured by deep inelastic neutron scattering’ by Y. Finkelstein and R. Moreh”",
abstract = "We reply to the comment [Front. Phys. 14(5), 53605 (2019)] by Y. Finkelstein and R. Moreh on our articleFront. Phys. 13(1), 138205(2018).Weagreewithsomeoftheircriticismsaboutourcalculation of the temperature effect on the kinetic energy of hydrogen atoms of supercooled confined water; we also agree with their statement that, in view of the current sensitivity of the technique, possible effects oftheliquid–liquidwatertransitionarehardlydetectedwithdeepinelasticneutronscattering(DINS). However, we disagree with their use of the translational mass ratio of a single water molecule and, in general, with their underestimation of collective effects.",
keywords = "deep inelastic neutron scattering, libration, liquid-liquid transition, proton kinetic energy, supercooled water, vibrational density of states",
author = "Antonio Cupane and Giovanni Romanelli",
year = "2019",
language = "English",
volume = "14",
journal = "Frontiers of Physics",
issn = "2095-0462",
publisher = "Springer Science + Business Media",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Reply to “Comment to ‘Dynamics of supercooled confined water measured by deep inelastic neutron scattering’ by Y. Finkelstein and R. Moreh”

AU - Cupane, Antonio

AU - Romanelli, Giovanni

PY - 2019

Y1 - 2019

N2 - We reply to the comment [Front. Phys. 14(5), 53605 (2019)] by Y. Finkelstein and R. Moreh on our articleFront. Phys. 13(1), 138205(2018).Weagreewithsomeoftheircriticismsaboutourcalculation of the temperature effect on the kinetic energy of hydrogen atoms of supercooled confined water; we also agree with their statement that, in view of the current sensitivity of the technique, possible effects oftheliquid–liquidwatertransitionarehardlydetectedwithdeepinelasticneutronscattering(DINS). However, we disagree with their use of the translational mass ratio of a single water molecule and, in general, with their underestimation of collective effects.

AB - We reply to the comment [Front. Phys. 14(5), 53605 (2019)] by Y. Finkelstein and R. Moreh on our articleFront. Phys. 13(1), 138205(2018).Weagreewithsomeoftheircriticismsaboutourcalculation of the temperature effect on the kinetic energy of hydrogen atoms of supercooled confined water; we also agree with their statement that, in view of the current sensitivity of the technique, possible effects oftheliquid–liquidwatertransitionarehardlydetectedwithdeepinelasticneutronscattering(DINS). However, we disagree with their use of the translational mass ratio of a single water molecule and, in general, with their underestimation of collective effects.

KW - deep inelastic neutron scattering

KW - libration

KW - liquid-liquid transition

KW - proton kinetic energy

KW - supercooled water

KW - vibrational density of states

UR - http://hdl.handle.net/10447/380832

UR - http://www.springerlink.com/content/2095-0462/6/2/

M3 - Comment/debate

VL - 14

JO - Frontiers of Physics

JF - Frontiers of Physics

SN - 2095-0462

ER -