Measuring freedom of choice: an alternative view of a recent literature

Sebastiano Bavetta, Sebastiano Bavetta

Risultato della ricerca: Article

11 Citazioni (Scopus)

Abstract

A recent literature has emerged in social choice theory which attributes intrinsic importance to freedom in the evaluation of states of affairs. The literature’s philosophical basis lies in Berlin’s notion of positive liberty. Accordingly, axiomatic measures of availability of choices are developed and the information they convey used for ranking states on the basis of the extent of liberty they offer to individuals.This paper argues that the literature’s contributions have taken Berlin’s analytical framework for granted exceedingly narrowing the philosophical terms of the debate. It is shown that, once freedom is analyzed from the perspective of an alternative structure, the triadic syntax of MacCallum, new normative content can be given to the literature and a more appropriate role can also be provided for its philosophical dimension.In particular, a correspondence between measures and conceptions of liberty is established on the basis of MacCallum’s framework and two conclusions are defended. The first is that the literature is concerned with the measurement of liberty, despite some contrary claims. The second that at least three alternative interpretations of freedom can be envisaged by the analysis of the literature’s contributions.Some brief, final considerations about the appropriateness of the liter- ature’s treatment of freedom are also made.
Lingua originaleEnglish
pagine (da-a)29-48
Numero di pagine20
RivistaSocial Choice and Welfare
Volume22
Stato di pubblicazionePublished - 2004

Fingerprint

decision making leeway
Berlin
literature
Freedom of choice
syntax
ranking
interpretation
Liberty
evaluation

All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes

  • Social Sciences (miscellaneous)
  • Economics and Econometrics

Cita questo

Measuring freedom of choice: an alternative view of a recent literature. / Bavetta, Sebastiano; Bavetta, Sebastiano.

In: Social Choice and Welfare, Vol. 22, 2004, pag. 29-48.

Risultato della ricerca: Article

@article{8042c912d96d4508b095051710e2f271,
title = "Measuring freedom of choice: an alternative view of a recent literature",
abstract = "A recent literature has emerged in social choice theory which attributes intrinsic importance to freedom in the evaluation of states of affairs. The literature’s philosophical basis lies in Berlin’s notion of positive liberty. Accordingly, axiomatic measures of availability of choices are developed and the information they convey used for ranking states on the basis of the extent of liberty they offer to individuals.This paper argues that the literature’s contributions have taken Berlin’s analytical framework for granted exceedingly narrowing the philosophical terms of the debate. It is shown that, once freedom is analyzed from the perspective of an alternative structure, the triadic syntax of MacCallum, new normative content can be given to the literature and a more appropriate role can also be provided for its philosophical dimension.In particular, a correspondence between measures and conceptions of liberty is established on the basis of MacCallum’s framework and two conclusions are defended. The first is that the literature is concerned with the measurement of liberty, despite some contrary claims. The second that at least three alternative interpretations of freedom can be envisaged by the analysis of the literature’s contributions.Some brief, final considerations about the appropriateness of the liter- ature’s treatment of freedom are also made.",
keywords = "OPPORTUNITY, PREFERENCE",
author = "Sebastiano Bavetta and Sebastiano Bavetta",
year = "2004",
language = "English",
volume = "22",
pages = "29--48",
journal = "Social Choice and Welfare",
issn = "0176-1714",
publisher = "Springer New York",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Measuring freedom of choice: an alternative view of a recent literature

AU - Bavetta, Sebastiano

AU - Bavetta, Sebastiano

PY - 2004

Y1 - 2004

N2 - A recent literature has emerged in social choice theory which attributes intrinsic importance to freedom in the evaluation of states of affairs. The literature’s philosophical basis lies in Berlin’s notion of positive liberty. Accordingly, axiomatic measures of availability of choices are developed and the information they convey used for ranking states on the basis of the extent of liberty they offer to individuals.This paper argues that the literature’s contributions have taken Berlin’s analytical framework for granted exceedingly narrowing the philosophical terms of the debate. It is shown that, once freedom is analyzed from the perspective of an alternative structure, the triadic syntax of MacCallum, new normative content can be given to the literature and a more appropriate role can also be provided for its philosophical dimension.In particular, a correspondence between measures and conceptions of liberty is established on the basis of MacCallum’s framework and two conclusions are defended. The first is that the literature is concerned with the measurement of liberty, despite some contrary claims. The second that at least three alternative interpretations of freedom can be envisaged by the analysis of the literature’s contributions.Some brief, final considerations about the appropriateness of the liter- ature’s treatment of freedom are also made.

AB - A recent literature has emerged in social choice theory which attributes intrinsic importance to freedom in the evaluation of states of affairs. The literature’s philosophical basis lies in Berlin’s notion of positive liberty. Accordingly, axiomatic measures of availability of choices are developed and the information they convey used for ranking states on the basis of the extent of liberty they offer to individuals.This paper argues that the literature’s contributions have taken Berlin’s analytical framework for granted exceedingly narrowing the philosophical terms of the debate. It is shown that, once freedom is analyzed from the perspective of an alternative structure, the triadic syntax of MacCallum, new normative content can be given to the literature and a more appropriate role can also be provided for its philosophical dimension.In particular, a correspondence between measures and conceptions of liberty is established on the basis of MacCallum’s framework and two conclusions are defended. The first is that the literature is concerned with the measurement of liberty, despite some contrary claims. The second that at least three alternative interpretations of freedom can be envisaged by the analysis of the literature’s contributions.Some brief, final considerations about the appropriateness of the liter- ature’s treatment of freedom are also made.

KW - OPPORTUNITY

KW - PREFERENCE

UR - http://hdl.handle.net/10447/18271

M3 - Article

VL - 22

SP - 29

EP - 48

JO - Social Choice and Welfare

JF - Social Choice and Welfare

SN - 0176-1714

ER -