Experimental assessment of the backoff behavior of commercial IEEE 802.11b network cards

Ilenia Tinnirello, Luca Scalia, Giuseppe Costantino Giaconia, Giuseppe Bianchi, Antonio Di Stefano, Gabriella Terrazzino, Giuseppe Bianchi

Risultato della ricerca: Other

79 Citazioni (Scopus)

Abstract

It has been observed that different IEEE 802.11 commercial cards produced by different vendors experience different performance, either when accessing alone the channel, as well as when competing against each other. These differences persist also when thorough measurement methodologies (such as RF shielding, laptop rotation, etc) are applied, and alignment of the environmental factors (same laptop models, traffic generators, etc) is carried out. This paper provides an extensive experimental characterization of the backoff operation of six commercial NIC cards. It suggests a relevant methodological approach, namely a repeatable, well defined, set of experiments, for such a characterization. Low level backoff distribution measurements are taken through a custom equipment developed in our laboratory. Our work allows to detect both a non-standard backoff behavior of some commercial cards (in terms of minimum contention window size and neglection of EIFS times), as well as potential implementation limits (in either the card hardware/firmware and/or the software driver) which appear to severely alter the card performance in challenging conditions.
Lingua originaleEnglish
Pagine1181-1189
Numero di pagine9
Stato di pubblicazionePublished - 2007

Fingerprint

Firmware
Shielding
Computer hardware
Experiments

All Science Journal Classification (ASJC) codes

  • Computer Science(all)
  • Electrical and Electronic Engineering

Cita questo

Experimental assessment of the backoff behavior of commercial IEEE 802.11b network cards. / Tinnirello, Ilenia; Scalia, Luca; Giaconia, Giuseppe Costantino; Bianchi, Giuseppe; Di Stefano, Antonio; Terrazzino, Gabriella; Bianchi, Giuseppe.

2007. 1181-1189.

Risultato della ricerca: Other

@conference{f7c9fd9a668b4a6fab8dfa37e7800b22,
title = "Experimental assessment of the backoff behavior of commercial IEEE 802.11b network cards",
abstract = "It has been observed that different IEEE 802.11 commercial cards produced by different vendors experience different performance, either when accessing alone the channel, as well as when competing against each other. These differences persist also when thorough measurement methodologies (such as RF shielding, laptop rotation, etc) are applied, and alignment of the environmental factors (same laptop models, traffic generators, etc) is carried out. This paper provides an extensive experimental characterization of the backoff operation of six commercial NIC cards. It suggests a relevant methodological approach, namely a repeatable, well defined, set of experiments, for such a characterization. Low level backoff distribution measurements are taken through a custom equipment developed in our laboratory. Our work allows to detect both a non-standard backoff behavior of some commercial cards (in terms of minimum contention window size and neglection of EIFS times), as well as potential implementation limits (in either the card hardware/firmware and/or the software driver) which appear to severely alter the card performance in challenging conditions.",
author = "Ilenia Tinnirello and Luca Scalia and Giaconia, {Giuseppe Costantino} and Giuseppe Bianchi and {Di Stefano}, Antonio and Gabriella Terrazzino and Giuseppe Bianchi",
year = "2007",
language = "English",
pages = "1181--1189",

}

TY - CONF

T1 - Experimental assessment of the backoff behavior of commercial IEEE 802.11b network cards

AU - Tinnirello, Ilenia

AU - Scalia, Luca

AU - Giaconia, Giuseppe Costantino

AU - Bianchi, Giuseppe

AU - Di Stefano, Antonio

AU - Terrazzino, Gabriella

AU - Bianchi, Giuseppe

PY - 2007

Y1 - 2007

N2 - It has been observed that different IEEE 802.11 commercial cards produced by different vendors experience different performance, either when accessing alone the channel, as well as when competing against each other. These differences persist also when thorough measurement methodologies (such as RF shielding, laptop rotation, etc) are applied, and alignment of the environmental factors (same laptop models, traffic generators, etc) is carried out. This paper provides an extensive experimental characterization of the backoff operation of six commercial NIC cards. It suggests a relevant methodological approach, namely a repeatable, well defined, set of experiments, for such a characterization. Low level backoff distribution measurements are taken through a custom equipment developed in our laboratory. Our work allows to detect both a non-standard backoff behavior of some commercial cards (in terms of minimum contention window size and neglection of EIFS times), as well as potential implementation limits (in either the card hardware/firmware and/or the software driver) which appear to severely alter the card performance in challenging conditions.

AB - It has been observed that different IEEE 802.11 commercial cards produced by different vendors experience different performance, either when accessing alone the channel, as well as when competing against each other. These differences persist also when thorough measurement methodologies (such as RF shielding, laptop rotation, etc) are applied, and alignment of the environmental factors (same laptop models, traffic generators, etc) is carried out. This paper provides an extensive experimental characterization of the backoff operation of six commercial NIC cards. It suggests a relevant methodological approach, namely a repeatable, well defined, set of experiments, for such a characterization. Low level backoff distribution measurements are taken through a custom equipment developed in our laboratory. Our work allows to detect both a non-standard backoff behavior of some commercial cards (in terms of minimum contention window size and neglection of EIFS times), as well as potential implementation limits (in either the card hardware/firmware and/or the software driver) which appear to severely alter the card performance in challenging conditions.

UR - http://hdl.handle.net/10447/21323

M3 - Other

SP - 1181

EP - 1189

ER -